| Sheriff | Years Active |
|---|---|
| Tim Lane | 2017 - Present |
| Dennis Conard | 2001 - 2017 |
| Richard Huff | 2000 - 2001 |
| Michael Bladel | 1993 - 2000 |
| Forrest F. Ashcraft | 1979 - 1993 |
| Dale Hackett | 1978 - 1979 |
| Kenneth Paulson | 1973 - 1978 |
| William A. Strout | 1964 - 1973 |
| C. H. (Pete) Wildman | 1950 - 1964 |
| Walter Buese | 1937 - 1950 |
| Frank D. Martin | 1925 - 1937 |
| William Brehmer | 1920 - 1925 |
| Henry A. Kuehl | 1917 - 1920 |
| Louis Eckhart | 1906 - 1917 |
| E. G. McArthur | 1897 - 1906 |
| Harvey J. Jones | 1891 - 1897 |
| Nathaniel Leonard | 1881 - 1891 |
| Harvey Leonard | 1871 - 1881 |
| Gustav Schnitger | 1867 - 1871 |
| John M. Lyter | 1863 - 1867 |
| James Thorington | 1858 - 1863 |
| Harvey Leonard | 1847 - 1858 |
| A. H. Davenport | 1842 - 1847 |
| Frazer Wilson | 1838 - 1842 |